Podcast Summary: Verify a candidate's identity first, then run a role-appropriate background screen after a conditional job offer, and screen everyone hired for the same role the same way. That's the core advice from Ian Bellais, Executive Vice President of Strategy at Verified First, on the latest episode of Testing, Testing 1-2-3.
Hosts Jenny Arnez and Michael Callen, President of TestGenius, sit down with Ian to unpack background screening and ID verification in plain English. Expect practical tips, a few laughs, and more than one confession from a self-described "former knucklehead."
Watch the full episode on YouTube · Listen at podcast.testgenius.com
Free resource: Download the TestGenius + Verified First partner one-sheet (PDF)
Run the background check after the conditional job offer goes out. By then you've completed the testing and interviews and decided this is the right person. Screening last keeps bias out of earlier decisions and avoids spending money on candidates you won't hire.
As Ian describes it, the employer has done the skills testing, held the interviews, and found a great fit. Then the offer goes out, conditional on the background screen.
ID verification confirms that a candidate is who they claim to be, and that the license or Social Security number they provided really belongs to them. Ian's shorthand: make sure "Ian is Ian."
It's becoming more critical as AI makes fake identities easier to produce. Many Verified First customers now use ID verification as the entryway to the background screen. If the identity checks out, the screen proceeds. If it doesn't, the employer stops before paying to screen someone who handed over a false ID. It's especially important in fields like transportation, where you must know the driver you hired is the person holding that license.
And no, nobody needs to bring in their Social Security card anymore. Today's tools trace the number against databases to confirm it belongs to the candidate.
It depends on the role. Verified First offers several hundred screens, but for most frontline jobs (Ian's example: a pizza delivery driver), the four essentials are:
For executives, security positions, and other critical roles, employers typically add federal searches, credit checks, education and employment verification, and ongoing criminal monitoring. Other options include drug screening and international screens.
Verified First's sales team reviews the roles, states, and even counties a customer hires in. A dedicated reviewer then checks for gaps during and after the sale, and account managers keep customers updated as laws change.
Yes to both, according to Ian. Background checks do more than flag criminal records. They protect your company, investors, and employees, and a bad hire can damage culture and trust far beyond one desk. Even frontline hires matter, because coworkers want to know the people around them are safe.
Rescreening matters too, especially before a promotion or for sensitive roles. Verified First rescreens all of its own employees, Ian included, every year on their work anniversary. His reminder: the person you hired 12 months ago may not be the same person today. Roles like commercial drivers often carry random drug screens for the same reason.
Background screening companies are consumer reporting agencies (CRAs), regulated by the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA). Employers also need to follow EEOC guidance plus state and local laws, including Ban the Box rules.
The golden rule is consistency: screen everyone who applies for the same role the same way. (Mike points out it's the same principle behind fair pre-employment testing.) Verified First builds role-based screening packages so a company with 100 recruiters stays as consistent as a company with one.
Which state's law applies? The state where the job is performed, not where the candidate lives or where the company is headquartered. If someone lives in Indiana but works in Chicago, Illinois law applies. Verified First keeps a library of state-specific forms and serves the right ones to each candidate automatically.
Ban the Box refers to laws that limit when employers can ask about criminal convictions. The name comes from the old "Have you ever been convicted of a crime?" checkbox on job applications.
Depending on the state, employers may not ask until after the application, after an interview, or after a conditional offer. The goal is to avoid shutting people out of work over a past mistake that doesn't affect whether they can do the job. These laws are a big reason background checks usually happen after the offer.
The standard look-back period is 7 to 10 years. The exact limit depends on state law, and employers can choose within that range.
It should be fast, clear, and fully digital. With Verified First, candidates sign short, state-specific forms electronically and finish their part in just a few minutes. If they have questions before, during, or after the screen, they can call or chat and reach a real person. A clunky process shouldn't be the reason a great candidate drops out.
Yes. Remote work makes screening more important, not less. Remote employees often work unsupervised with access to critical systems, and hiring managers lose the in-person read they get from body language.
Digital screening and remote Form I-9 let employers hire in all 50 states. Remote roles also bring their own requirements. For example, people who run or review sensitive screens like credit checks need a private, secure workspace at home. Ian, a longtime work-from-home advocate, has seen Verified First go 100% remote since COVID using its own tools.
Skills testing confirms a candidate can do the job. Background screening confirms their history. Together they give employers a fuller, faster read on every candidate, from application to first day. That's the idea behind the TestGenius and Verified First partnership:
Candidate applies → TestGenius skills and ability testing → Verified First background screening → Onboard
Download the TestGenius + Verified First one-sheet (PDF)
Ready to pair the two? Visit verifiedfirst.com/partner/testgenius. To learn more about skills testing, head to testgenius.com.
Ian Bellais is the Executive Vice President of Strategy at Verified First, where he's worked for almost 10 years. He built the company's partner channel program, went on to lead marketing and sales, and now focuses on strategy, partnerships, and new products. His path was unplanned: a tech background, a call from a longtime friend who owns the company, and a visit to Boise, Idaho, where he fell for the city and the software.
Verified First is a privately owned, Idaho-based background screening provider. It covers the window between recruiting and onboarding: background checks, verifications, drug screening, ID verification, Form I-9, and E-Verify, with a Work Opportunity Tax Credit (WOTC) solution launching soon. Verified First is PBSA-accredited and reports a 98% client satisfaction rating.
This recap only scratches the surface. Tune in to hear Ian's take on everything from Social Security cards in the 1970s to what a college reunion teaches you about second chances, plus plenty of banter with Mike and Jenny.
Watch on YouTube · Listen at podcast.testgenius.com
You can also find Testing, Testing 1-2-3 on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, and other podcast apps. Ian will be back for Part Two, so subscribe so you don't miss it!